Posts Tagged ‘pain’

Coercing Breath Tests With Threats of Pain

Tuesday, December 13th, 2011

I’ve written in the past about the growing practice of forcibly taking blood from a drunk driving suspect, sometimes done by a cop in the field.  See, for example, Taking Blood by Force, Forced Blood Draws by Cops: Constitutional?Forced Blood Draws by Cops SpreadingBlood Draws in the Back Seat by the Dashboard Light and Forced Blood Draws: Citizen Backlash?.   

Here’s a new tactic: threaten the suspect with strapping him down and painfully jabbing a needle into him (however many times it takes to get a blood sample)…unless he agrees to "voluntarily" take a breath test.

Texas Blood Test Aims at Drunk Drivers

Wall Street Journal, Dec. 11 —  Texans arrested for drunken driving should be prepared to give blood this holiday season.

Cities and counties across the state are increasingly demanding that drunken-driving suspects who refuse to take breathalyzer tests submit to blood tests that measure the amount of alcohol in their systems.

The blood-test policy—dubbed "no refusal" by law-enforcement officials, because it prevents drivers from refusing to provide evidence of intoxication—has grown from a novel procedure used in a few Texas jurisdictions to an initiative used by police statewide, particularly during weekends and holidays when drunken driving is most common. The no-refusal initiative has also caught on in other states, including Florida, Illinois, Louisiana and Missouri…

Texas courts have uniformly upheld the constitutionality of mandatory blood testing, attorneys said. But criminal-defense lawyers say such mandatory tests trample suspects’ rights to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. "It’s an erosion of civil liberties," said Austin defense lawyer Samuel Bassett. "If we can poke people involuntarily for evidence, where do we draw the line?"…

Police are empowered to strap a suspect to a chair, if necessary, to obtain a blood sample. That allows blood to be drawn quickly—a key benefit to prosecutors because blood-alcohol concentrations dissipate over time…

In El Paso, police find that the policy actually encourages people to submit to breath tests. "We give people the option of blowing into a tube or getting poked with a needle," said Lt. Rod Liston. "People increasingly are going with the less painful option."…

Hmmm…Threatening to "poke" a suspect with a needle actually "encourages" him to submit to a breath test?  What a surprise!  But I guess this wouldn’t be "torture" using the Attorney General’s definition requiring organ failure.

So:  "Submit to a breath test…or we’ll strap you into a chair and jam needles into you."   Welcome to the War on Terrorism…I mean, Drunk Driving.
 

DUI BLOG

Woman charged with DWI over pain medication

Thursday, November 10th, 2011

Most Greenville residents know that North Carolina law prohibits drunk driving. But not all people may be aware that North Carolina DWI laws also prohibit impaired driving related to prescription medications. Recently, a Trinity woman was charged with DWI on allegations that her pain medication impaired her ability to drive.

North Carolina law enforcement officers claim the woman was first seen speeding on I-85. Troopers say they clocked the woman traveling 104 miles per hour on the Interstate around 12:15 last Tuesday. One of the troopers claims the woman nearly struck the trooper and several other cars. State Highway Patrol troopers also claim the woman eventually ran off the road and nearly struck a pole.

After all the allegations of nearly striking other objects, North Carolina troopers say the woman lost control of her Nissan 350Z, which spun out on the Interstate. State troopers say her vehicle wound up stopped in the southbound lane of I-85 facing toward the north. The Nissan reportedly showed no signs of damage and no accident occurred involving other vehicles, according to news reports. The Nissan was reportedly towed from the scene.

Troopers say the woman appeared confused after the alleged incident. Authorities claim the woman told officers that she was wearing a Fentanyl patch. Fentanyl is a prescription medication commonly used to treat chronic pain.

The 61-year-old woman was taken to Rowan Medical Center, where she apparently provided a blood sample. Law enforcement issued a citation later Tuesday, charging the woman with DWI and reckless driving.

Source: Salisbury Post, “Report: Woman went more than 100 mph while impaired,” Nathan Hardin, Nov. 2, 2011

Greenville DUI Attorney Blog | North Carolina Underage Drinking Lawyer | Pitt County First DUI Law Firm

Greyhound to passengers: Prove your pain

Saturday, July 30th, 2011

They’re suing Greyhound, claiming they can’t eat or work since being aboard the same bus as Vince Li, but the bus company not only denies liability, it even challenges them to prove they were negatively affected by what went on that day.
Manitoba stories